Broker onboarding
Where Brokers Lose New Clients Before the First Deposit
A B2Prime case and a practical way to diagnose where new brokerage clients drop out between registration, identity verification and their first deposit.
I proposed holding the budget for one of our acquisition channels at B2Prime. It was bringing in plenty of registrations. Very few of those people were passing identity verification (KYC). Our overall figures showed a similar drop, so I made the same case for acquisition spending more broadly. Before putting more money in, I wanted to know where people were getting stuck.
My first question was whether we were paying for bots. I pulled up the behaviour reports. The activity looked like people using the site, so I wanted to see what they were being asked to do. I went through the process myself and gave up on my first attempt.
I’d filled in a form and uploaded my passport. I still had details to type in, and there was another document to provide. Then came the selfie. By that point I’d already done quite a bit, and there was still work left. I could see why someone would stop there.
My instinct was to ask for the hard part earlier. If you’re ready to verify your identity, get the passport and selfie done while you’re there. Then the form can fill in the details it already has. We moved those steps up, used the passport to fill in fields such as name and date of birth, and added Google sign-in at registration.
Customers still had to complete the required checks. We also proposed Sumsub ID so people who had already saved document data with the provider could share it with their consent. I don’t have a clean measure of how much the changes we made affected first deposits. How Sumsub ID works
When people pass verification but don’t deposit
I also wanted to know what was happening to people who passed verification. When I looked at the figures by country, South Africa stood out. We were getting applicants from there, and at the time we didn’t offer deposits in South African rand. That was one possible reason people stopped before funding. To check it, I’d want to know how many approved applicants opened the cashier, what payment options they saw and whether they tried to use them.
After KYC, I’d show customers which funding options work in their country and how to use them. If people tried to deposit and hit an error, I’d take the failed attempts to Payments. I’d also ask Payments what it would take to offer a local currency if it was missing.
What I want from a brokerage onboarding funnel
For each channel, show me three numbers. How many people registered? How many passed KYC? How many made a first deposit? I look at the share of registrations that turn into verified accounts, then the share of verified accounts that fund. I also keep first deposits per registration on that same line. At B2Prime, organic search was one of the stronger channels in the figures I was looking at. For a decision about paid spend, I’d also compare similar paid groups in the same market.
Give each group the same time to make a first deposit. If you use a 30-day window, wait until everyone in the group has had those 30 days. Count each person once, keep demo-only and existing clients separate, and check that the sign-up, verification and payment records refer to the same people.
Broker onboarding metrics I ask each team to bring
| Stage | Count | Who checks the drop |
|---|---|---|
| Sign-up | Registrations completed out of sign-ups started. | Marketing and Product. What did people come for, and where did they leave the form? |
| Verification submitted | People who submitted at least one application, out of registrants who need verification. Separate those who never started from those who started and stopped. | Product and Compliance. Which screen or document causes trouble? |
| Verification approved | People whose verification was approved, out of those who submitted. Count each person once. Show pending reviews, resubmission requests, refusals and time to decision separately. | Verification Operations and Compliance. Where are cases waiting, and why? |
| Deposit attempted | People who try to deposit out of those eligible to fund. | Product and Payments. Can the customer find the cashier and use a suitable method and currency? |
| First deposit credited | People with a first deposit credited to their account out of those who try. Show pending payments separately. | Payments. Did authentication fail, did the provider decline it, or did an approved payment fail to reach the balance? |
Before asking Product to change a verification screen, I’d check when people submitted their documents. If most of those applications are still awaiting a decision, I’d start with the review queue. I’d also check for a payment attempt before treating an unfunded account as a payment failure. Sumsub’s verification statuses · Stripe’s card decline codes
What I’d need to see before adding spend
I was prepared to reopen the budget discussion once the share of registrants passing KYC moved closer to the rate we saw in a comparable group. Where possible, I’d compare the old and new journeys over the same period, for people in the same market who came from the same source.
Before adding spend, I’d still check whether more people went on to make a first deposit and what each newly funded account cost us.